On Being a Good Queer

For years on October 11, I have been saying the same thing on social media: you don’t owe it to anybody to come out, today or any other day of the year. You don’t have to give that information to everyone in your life, even people you know would only hurt you with it. You don’t owe it to anyone to perform the labor of that conversation, or to keep existing in their life as the openly Queer person they know who makes them rethink their own biases. I have distilled this point of view as follows: We don’t owe the straights jack shit.

This year circumstances led me to having those conversations with people I knew would not receive them well. But I did it purposefully, and most importantly I did it for me and not for them.

Coming out to my parents went terribly. I knew that it was going to, which is why for years beforehand I didn’t do it. Because I didn’t owe them that. I also didn’t owe them the labor of hiding who I was; I just lived and existed and was Queer as a fucking three-dollar bill for literal years, and let the decision to recognize that or not fall on them instead of on myself.

Unsurprisingly, they elected not to do that. Perhaps also unsurprisingly, they mostly (after an initial spate of verbal abuse from my father) coped with my coming out by trying to continue to not acknowledge my Queer identity. They seemed to want to move forward by awkwardly existing around my full personhood, like my being Queer was a missing step or a hole in the floor that, if they couldn’t make it go away, they could just steer around indefinitely.

That’s not fucking okay. And I’m still hurt and I’m still mad and I probably always will be, that they failed me so spectacularly in that regard.

I don’t talk to my parents any more, and I want to be especially clear: that’s a choice from my end, not theirs. I made it clear that I would reopen communication with my father if he apologized for the way he behaved. He has not done that. I asked my mother to talk about my coming out and my wife’s coming out with me. Her response was that she wasn’t going to do that, because I already knew what they would say. And hey, you know what? She was right.

They periodically reach out to me. They express interest in maintaining contact with me, and with my child. Not with my wife, whose existence they have pointedly refused to acknowledge. And not with me as a Queer woman. The closest I’ve gotten to an acknowledgment from my mother is I’m sorry I can’t give you what you want, like treating me as a fully human person is a video game she couldn’t afford. The closest I’ve gotten to an apology from my father is I don’t know what I did to deserve being treated this way, which is . . . typical, honestly.

So I don’t talk to my parents any more. Because I was right before this year; I didn’t owe them the pain I put myself through to come out to them. And I don’t owe them the humiliation and hurt of being a Good Queer who suffers through their lack of acknowledgement and refusal to change. I don’t owe it to them to grin and bear an existence where they get to have me in their lives without thinking, for one single moment, about how their beliefs and their politics hurt me and the people like me who I love. It’s not my job to stay in their world, hurting and humiliated, until watching me suffer makes them magically decide to be better people.

I don’t owe them that. And if you’re reading this and you’re Queer, I want you to know that you don’t owe that to anyone in your life either. You can absolutely choose to remove yourself from the lives of those who don’t deserve you. You can be beautifully Queer and free and out to those who will cherish you in the beauty of your being, in the wholeness of your heart.

So. Happy Coming Out Day, my loves. You don’t owe the straights jack shit, and you don’t have to be a Good Queer. You can just be yourself.

On Living Past 25

There is no normal life, Wyatt. There’s just life. So get on with it.

Val Kilmer as Doc Holliday, Tombstone (1993)

Yesterday was my birthday. I’m 35 now, an age I did not imagine I would ever reach when I was a child. To be honest, I imagined very few things for myself that involved anything real. I imagined being a superhero, or a space explorer, or an underground outlaw doing right by the downtrodden. I never imagined a normal life for myself. Never pictured myself married or parenting or growing old, because I would not be there for those things. I didn’t want to be dead when I grew up, exactly; I just knew with a certainty I never questioned that I would not live past 25.

I’m told this is a shared experience for a lot of Queer kids, especially those of us who could recognize and label our Queerness for what it was and who never saw happy, thriving, living Queer adults in any of the media they consumed or the communities they lived in. My experience was a little apart from that specific one; I didn’t “know I liked girls”, I just knew I wasn’t the same as the rest of the people around me. I never consciously connected my certainty that survival past 25 wasn’t in the cards with a specific part of my identity. Whether that means this shared certainty transcends our early access to terms for our Queerness, or whether that means it stems from some other space, that I don’t know.

Regardless. The best decade of my life is the one I lived after I woke up at 25 and kept on waking up every day thereafter. It’s like I woke up that day and, given that I was now apparently alive for the long haul, I gave myself permission to create the best possible life out of the rich vein of time I’d just uncovered. I got married and had a child and stumbled face-first into my life’s work as an anti-racist educator, as an activist. I found the safety and freedom to finally name the difference I carried through the first quarter-century of my life, to finally call myself Queer.

I dug deep into therapy and medicated the illness that tried very hard to kill me when I was twenty. I built boundaries by brute force and walked away when people couldn’t keep them. I realized nobody had ever taught me how to be a decent spouse, and I grabbed my wife’s hand and said Teach me, show me, we have to learn this because I have to live now and I’m not doing it without you. I realized all the ways I didn’t know how to avoid my parent’s mistakes, and I found people to teach me and books to fill my gaps because I’m going to live now, and I refuse to live with doing less than right by my child.

I realized the world wasn’t going to end in the religious catastrophe I’d been assured, and that God was not going to fantastically intervene in the injustice around me, and I said okay well fuck it, I have to live here and I’m not leaving it like this. Which maybe, I’ve realized over the last decade of living, is the only kind of intervening in the world’s injustice that anything or anybody ever did to begin with.

My life after 25 is blessedly, outrageously Queer and ferociously, happily normal. It’s the life I — a kid who daydreamed like I was on the goddamned clock doing it, a child with vivid imagination scrawled on her entire general person — didn’t have the imagination to construct for myself, until the day I suddenly did.

I imagined it and I built it and now I get to live in it, for however long it happens to last.

And that is a hell of a thing.

What I learned from walking in circles.

Our local library recently opened a permanent labyrinth installation on the library grounds. It’s a lovely setup, and since one of my many hats is Big Ol’ Medievalism Nerd I was excited to explain a little bit about the history and significance of the concept to my kid.

We’ve walked it twice together so far. I’ve walked labyrinths for meditative purposes before, but it is actually remarkably hard to meditate effectively when a charging-ahead six-year-old emphatically demands a high five any time you pass one another along the labyrinth way. My explanation that this space was created to be a walk done at a thoughtful pace did not hold water with someone who looked down and saw BIG OL’ STONE MAZE TIME.

My child is an absolute treasure. A good listener, thoughtful, gentle, overall easy to parent. But children are ultimately still children. Mine rocketed ahead of me, holding out a hand for a high five every time we passed, stopping only when I was not moving at a sufficiently brisk pace.

Children are loud. They are obstinate. They are emphatic and pushy and demanding and aggressive and, in general, distressingly human. And sometimes all I want is for shoes to go on feet, ass to go in car seat, Minecraft to be turned off so we can eat dinner before it’s midnight, et cetera. And all the kid wants is, apparently, to do exactly the opposite of that thing as fast as humanly possible.

Sometimes my kid is charging in the opposite direction from me, when I’m just trying to get centered and go at a reasonable pace.

And yet, I thought, as I watched myself reach out every time to give what my child needed and wanted from me, contact across the invisible space between us. And yet, we are going to the same center, even when we’re moving in the opposite direction.

Even as I type this it seems like the kind of incredibly pat and too-perfect nonsense that parenting blogs so often indulge in. Like this moment of zen and connection in the labyrinth magically kept me from later getting impatient when a four-minute walk to the library building became a drawn out affair that took nearly fifteen even though we were running almost-late for a kid’s event and I really needed to pee. Reader, it did no such thing.

But it was a nice moment. One I could stand to try and remember more often.

We’re moving towards the same place, even when we’re working at it in opposite directions.

On Moon Day

Moon Day is a holiday in our household. I think it started as kind of a joke when the kid was little, when every new thing presented an opportunity to make something new and kind of silly that was just ours, the three of us.

At some point it got more serious, in the sense that it’s still a very casual holiday but it’s no longer just something we flippantly say in the morning on July 20. “Happy Moon Day!” We have cake. We commemorate Apollo’s landing. This year we had a party, with a ton of food and friends and board games. I made a layer cake and my kid and my oldest nephew helped me decorate it with craters and edible silver spray paint.

Things change. Things that were silly become sacred. Things that filled the whole of your sky like the brightest, fullest harvest moon of all slip away and shrink to a silver sliver and then, sometimes, they’re gone.

Earlier today I told the kids a couple stories about my childhood, which happened less than a mile from where I’m typing this now. They were sweet memories, vague recollections of happy times, populated largely with people I may never see again. I left that part out, because it is Moon Day and today is not a sad holiday. It’s a day for commemorating an act of courage and hope and stunning human insolence. Today is for remembering we can take steps that those who came before us never dared even conceive of. It’s a very Queer holiday, when you think about it.

I had to spend part of today re-emphasizing a boundary with someone who took me and my wife’s coming out badly. It wasn’t a happy experience. It hurt and I second-guessed myself all the way through it. And I thought the same thing I thought when I was first preparing to share our news: you know this could be a goodbye. And who knows, maybe it is.

Sometimes lights go out and don’t rekindle. Sometimes people can’t change. Sometimes you leave things behind you didn’t want to lose, because they are too heavy to carry with you on the next part of the trip to whatever impossible place you are going.

But who knows. Sometimes against all odds a ship made of featherweight foolishness is lofted up on currents of math and audacity and touches a new world. Sometimes the once-dark moon is in a waxing crescent, and the world holds its breath and a new thing happens, inconcievable, incandescent.

Sometimes it’s Moon Day. Sometimes that’s enough to get by on for now.

Part II: Why I Came Out to My Parents

I almost had the conversation with my parents half a dozen times. When my mother responded to a magazine article including a lesbian couple’s wedding photo with “Ugh, gross.” When the Supreme Court ruled for equal marriage. When it became clear in 2016 that my parents and people like them had successfully put evil men who hated my people in power.

Every time, I walked myself back from the decision. It would not bring me joy, or closure, or a miracle change of heart in these people who I loved but could not trust. It would not make things better.

And my parents were, if not perfect, still people who I loved and could not quite imagine losing. They were mostly good grandparents to my child, who adored them. They were willing to listen to me when I laid down boundaries about what kind of things I wouldn’t tolerate being said around my family. It was painful, imperfect, but enough.

But things change. In our case, my spouse began her medical and social transition. And from the moment she told me she was pretty sure she wasn’t a man, I knew our imperfect balance with my parents was no longer acceptable. Maybe it never had been.

I was ready to tell them that day, but it was several very long months before I finally did. I waited until my wife was ready, because it was ultimately as much her story as mine. I talked to her, to my friends, to my therapist.

Eventually, I wrote my parents a letter. I told them I was bisexual, that my wife was a trans woman, that we would be staying married, that our child already knew and was adjusting well. I invited them to stay part of our lives if they could do it with love and respect, that I’d answer questions if they were asked respectfully, that I wanted them to take time if they needed it.

My father responded by texting me a verbally abusive message as soon as they received the letter. I blocked his number and set up filters so that emails, if he sent them, would be set aside until I was able to cope with them.

My mother said nothing for weeks. We had previously spoken every single day on the phone for at least a few minutes. Eventually she made a sporadic attempt to re-establish contact, but she did it by refusing to discuss the subject of my family or her silence. Eventually, I told her I wasn’t going to pretend things were unchanged between us. That was the last conversation we had.

I don’t know if they’ll change. I don’t believe that they will. A certain breed of American religion takes up too much space in the fabric of their lives. They are not people inclined to reconsider their positions. I sometimes wonder how I, raised by them, managed to become one.

But I was so fucking tired by the time I came out. I was tired of the labor involved in maintaining enough of an edited version of myself for them to love. I was tired of stress dreams and catastrophizing. I was ready to get on with the life I had built.

I am openly Queer with my friends, in my public teaching and writing, in the way I present to strangers. I love the life I have, the one my wife and I share, and I’m honestly done with wasting energy on trying to keep people in it who can’t love the people we actually are.

It’s still painful. I can’t imagine a universe in which it wouldn’t have been. I’m immensely glad that I didn’t come out when I was younger and more hopelessly dependent on my parents’ approval for my emotional well-being. As it stands, I’m surrounded by people every day who remind me that the person I really am is worthy of loving and knowing wholly — and that is a beautiful relief.

Part I: Why I didn’t come out to my parents.

I didn’t come out to my parents as a child, although I was a Queer child, because I lived in an environment that had been meticulously scrubbed of any language I could have used to understand myself and what I felt. My aunt lived with a woman, a Butch truck driver with whom my aunt had a mutual subscription to The Advocate. I knew the word “lesbians” because Ellen had been on television. But my aunt had been married to men in the past, and lesbians hated men.

I didn’t come out to my parents as a teenager, although I was a Queer teenager, because religion had become the only framework on which stability in my household was constructed. Gay was something men were sometimes tempted to be, but it was a wrong choice to make (and oh, I was a very good girl who made as few wrong choices as possible, there was so very little room for wrong choices in my world). Lesbian was something women were if they hated men (and it was a choice you would someday walk back, as my aunt had walked back from the woman with strong hands and a cigarette voice who was never mentioned again). There was no word for both. And if feelings stirred in my guts, if my heart twisted up at a boy’s smile or the way he laughed, that was just Temptation. When the same feeling twisted my heart at the way a girl’s hair fell oh just so while she was praying, it was the Spirit of the Lord stirring me at her devotion, and if I wanted to follow her like a lost puppy it was because someday, I wanted to be just like her.

I didn’t come out to my parents as a young adult because they had made it clear how disgusting gay people were, and even if I now had somehow fluttered into a better frame of mind, how could I risk making them so angry? It wasn’t as if I was gay. Just sometimes overcome with longing for a girl’s company, sometimes breathless at how good she was or how her smile made things shine. But I would date a man, someday, and marry a man, someday, and then someday came along and that question was surely settled.

I didn’t come out to my parents at thirty, even though I had words now that I wasn’t afraid to use for myself — bisexual, Queer, gay as fuck — even though I used them riotously and joyously and even though I wanted wanted wanted to wrap my community around myself and screech with joy for finally having things (so many things) make sense. Because I still knew that conversation would lead me nowhere fast.

Because they did not stop being the people who taught me from the first day of my life that good choices were what I was expected to make. Because I heard enough contempt and disgust in their voices along the way of a thirty-five-year journey with them to know what they would say. Because somehow without any words on the subject passing between us I knew we will love you no matter what is a lie at least as often as it is the truth.

Because I did not owe it to them to be the Good Queer that would make them reconsider. I did not owe them the self-flagellation of a conversation that would only hurt me and bring me no joy or closure.

So I did not come out to my parents when I was nine, fourteen, twenty-two, thirty. I did not come out to my parents.

Until I did.